Next time you hear the president talk about how we need to tax more people like Warren Buffett – someone who, as of late, frequently advocates for higher taxation on the rich – should keep this in mind:
The “Buffett Rule” would not tax the vast majority of his shielded income, including either his unrealized capital gains, which are currently taxed at zero percent, or charitable contributions, which are tax deductible.
If the “Buffett Rule” were applied as President Obama proposes, then Mr. Buffett’s federal tax bill would have been $14.4 million, rather than the $6.9 million he actually paid. As a fraction of his true income, his effective tax rate would only have risen from 6/100ths of 1% to 12/100ths of 1%.
It turns out that all of Obama’s tax increases wouldn’t actually make any real difference in Buffett’s own taxes. But the hypocrisy of everyone involved worse:
Mr. Buffett’s donation to the Gates Foundation goes to the heart of my critique of his public call for higher tax rates on the rich. Just look at the second contractual condition for his ongoing pledge to the Gates Foundation: “The foundation must continue to satisfy the legal requirements qualifying Warren’s gift as charitable, exempt from gift or other taxes.”
In other words, if his gift weren’t tax sheltered he wouldn’t give it. So much for “shared sacrifice.”
Incidentally, I’m not the first to question Mr. Buffett’s commitment to “shared sacrifice” in balancing the federal budget. In a 2007 CNBC interview, when asked why he shelters his money through tax-free strategies rather than writing big checks to Uncle Sam, Mr. Buffett responded: “I think that on balance the Gates Foundation, my daughter’s foundation, my two sons’ foundations will do a better job with lower administrative costs and better selection of beneficiaries than the government.”
So Mr. Buffett thinks he and his family can put their money to better use than the government can. I guess he’s really not so different from the rest of us after all.
So Mr. Buffett isn’t really being honest with us after all… and neither is Obama. The richest 1% will continue to shelter their income with the help of an army of lawyers and accountants… and the hard-working upper-middle class who makes more than 250 thousand dollars… THEY will get foot with the bill. So much for ‘shared sacrifice’.
Via Class Warefare and the Buffett Rule — on WSJ.com